Page 1 of 1

Some Indian swallowtails and Pierids

Posted: Wed Apr 14, 2010 4:57 pm
by Padfield
Here's the final instalment of my Indian butterflies, including one picture I'd like some input on.

The swallowtails were in general hard to photograph, because they never stopped during the heat of the day. Many species nectared on the wing, tripping daintily over flowers and just dipping in. This first shot shows a male common Mormon, Papilio polytes, doing just that:

Image

Some females of this species have essentially the same colouration as the males, but others mimic one or other of the roses, Atrophaneura sp. This one mimics the crimson rose, Atrophaneura hector:

Image

Here is an awful shot of a real crimson rose:

Image

The crimson rose has a red body, while the Mormon has a dark body.


In Kolkata the commonest swallowtail was the common jay, Graphium doson:

Image

This is quite a small, tailless swallowtail, which glints metallic blue in flight.

In Mysore I found this larger, green, tailless swallowtail, which I can't place:

Image

If anyone has any input on that one I'd be interested to know.

European swallowtails, Papilio machaon, flew in the north and south but I didn't photograph any.

The commonest whites were the Catopsillia species. I think I saw both pomona (the common emigrant) and pyranthe (mottled emigrant) but I only got shots of pomona:

Image

This is instantly recognisable as being similar to the European common migrant, Catopsilia florella. It flew around trees in city centres everywhere.

Two grass yellows were common. The common grass yellow, Eurema hecabe, dominated in the north, and the three-spot grass yellow, Eurema blanda, in the south.

Image
(Common grass yellow)

Image
(Three-spot grass yellow - referring to the number of dark marks in the cell of the forewing)

Endemic to the Nilgir Hills is the Nilgiri clouded yellow, Colias nilagiriensis. This is a male roosting - the only time I found I could photograph a male:

Image

The books say females are rare but I actually saw plenty, and they were easier to photograph:

Image

This species is sometimes considered a subspecies of the European Colias erate, which also flies in India (but not in the Nilgiris).

In the botanic gardens in Ooty I think I saw Indian cabbage whites, but the only white I photographed there was this lesser gull, Cepora nadina:

Image

Elsewhere in Ooty, and in the hills, I saw the common albatross, Appias albina:

Image

This really was the holiday of a lifetime, and I don't mind giving a bit of free publicity to the company that made it possible, Art Safari (http://www.artsafari.co.uk/). The trip was tailor-made to our requirements, we took five flights altogether (Heathrow-Delhi, Delhi-Kolkata, Kolkata-Bangalore, Coimbatore-Mumbai, Mumbai-Heathrow), stayed in 5-star hotels, were met by agents at every airport, had guides and a car and a driver at our disposal at all times, and the cost came to under £2000 a head. That's way more than I would normally spend on a holiday and I will be paying it off for some time, but it's amazing value all the same. The chance to get to grips with the butterfly fauna of another continent, as well as all the other things we did, was wonderful.

Guy

Re: Some Indian swallowtails and Pierids

Posted: Wed Apr 14, 2010 5:14 pm
by Vince Massimo
Guy, I think your mystery swallowtail may be a Tailed Jay (Graphium agamemnon).

Cheers,

Vince

Re: Some Indian swallowtails and Pierids

Posted: Wed Apr 14, 2010 5:25 pm
by Padfield
Thanks, Vince - I think you're right! I was convinced that apparent tail was an illusion (partly because of a similar, but smaller, swallowtail I saw in Kolkata, which I called common jay in the end) but I've found another attempt at a shot which shows the tail really exists:

Image

That makes me very happy!!

Guy

EDIT

Here's the greenish-yellow one from Kolkata (again, not a presentable shot!!). Do you think it could be a form of common jay? It wasn't the only one like that:

Image

Re: Some Indian swallowtails and Pierids

Posted: Wed Apr 14, 2010 5:50 pm
by Vince Massimo
Guy, I only have "A Photographic Guide to Butterflies of Goa" by Parag Rangnekar as my source material, but I would say that the last photo is a Common Jay. I have seen a few images of this butterfly and they do seem to be quite variable. I am however still a bit worried about the amount of yellow colouring on yours. The only other candidate is the Common Bluebottle (Graphium sarpedon) but this has a predominatly greenish-blue central band so I have ruled that out.

Hope this helps.

Cheers,

Vince

Re: Some Indian swallowtails and Pierids

Posted: Wed Apr 14, 2010 5:58 pm
by Padfield
Thanks again, Vince. I'll do some more research when I get a moment. The colour in flight of this form was a little more green than appears in that picture, but still essentially yellow-green, rather than blue-green. The 'real' common jays were bright, metallic blue.

Guy

Re: Some Indian swallowtails and Pierids

Posted: Wed Apr 14, 2010 7:45 pm
by Dave McCormick
The Crimson Rose is one of my favourite swallowtails, nice find. I like the pale bluish/white colour on the common albatross. These are definatly species I hope to see in future :)